Beyond The Pitch - What a million kids have taught me about parenting
Tough Kid Questions: When Your Child Asks You Questions You Don’t Want To Answer

© jamesteohart / Adobe Stock

Tough Kid Questions: When Your Child Asks You Questions You Don’t Want To Answer

April 13, 2020

If you have a preschooler, you are well-versed in the “why” stage. Curious about everything, they are constantly asking for explanations. It’s cute (and at times exasperating), but what happens when kids, especially older kids, start asking questions that you don’t want to (or can’t) answer? Do you answer? Freeze? Lie? Avoid? Your response—or lack of a response—makes a difference and will impact how they choose to communicate with you later in life.

Kids are more aware and intuitive than we realize. They are actually like little scientists soaking up all they see and hear, cataloging it away for later use. Their early experiences shape their view of the world, how they form relationships and even how they engage in learning. So how and what we do really matters.

"How do babies get inside a mommy’s tummy?"

Setting the tone for answering difficult questions now will not only help form a solid foundation for your kiddo, it will do wonders for your relationship with them later in life. Children learn and internalize how you approach tough subjects. If you are open, honest and willing to engage they will learn that it is good to be curious, they are not a burden and that you are a trusted source. How you communicate with them influences whether they will continue to talk with you or shut down. Granted, at times you may want them to stop talking… I get that it can be exhausting. But, those open lines of communication are extremely important in the teenage years when the stakes are higher.

Here are some things to consider when reacting to tough questions.

Have patience

Having three kids, 15 nieces and nephews, plus working with little ones my entire career, I’ve had lots of experience with “why.” I’ve learned that a little patience really does go a long way. Showing patience and engaging in the conversation tells a child they’re important. It demonstrates your commitment to their learning and an appreciation for their curiosity. It also shows your willingness to talk to them about anything. So take a deep breath and, as they say, “lean in” to the conversation. Sometimes the questions are really just their way of trying to get closer to you. But, if you are at your wits end, you can always ask them what they think. That, too, let’s them know you value their thoughts.

Be OK with the discomfort

Kids ask some really hard questions. And the places they ask them can be really awkward. Target and the grocery store were some of my kids’ favorite places to belt out a hard-to-answer question. And volume control seemed to be an issue! (Why were they always so loud when they did it?) But EVERY parent who has brought a child out in public has been in this situation. So don’t worry about the real or perceived judgement you might feel. Just have grace for your child, yourself and other parents.

After all, curiosity is spontaneous and at times inconvenient. But often it is in response to something that triggers what’s going on in the home, in the news or what is immediately being seen. Usually kids are just trying to make sense of their world and when they see something that is unfamiliar they want to learn more or they want to make sure they’re safe. Lying to them or avoiding the question altogether doesn’t help. As you know, kids can be incessant when they want to know something. So try to keep cool, think on your feet and remember it’s okay to take a beat and think about your answer.

Be honest; age-appropriate, but honest

For most of us our first instinct is to protect our children. We want them to grow up feeling that the world is a safe place. We don’t want bad things to happen to them. We don’t want them to know the full truth about certain things. And that’s good—to a point.

There is a line we all draw when it comes to providing information. The trick is finding the delicate balance of how much is too much. If we overshare we run the risk of making our children grow up too fast. If we under-share we shelter them too much—hindering both the ability to have realistic expectations and develop resiliency. The dilemma is real.

My kids grew up in the era of 9/11, terrorist attacks, Sandy Hook, a recession and other horrific events. We kept their exposure to the news to a minimum, but the information was everywhere we turned and the questions felt nonstop. Those issues still prevail. And now we are quarantined facing a pandemic that is literally affecting everyone in the world. It’s natural for kids to notice, to question.

I believe it’s okay to acknowledge and talk about what is happening, if asked. Take your cues from your kids. Share bits of information, but tailor it to your child’s ability to understand the world. Keep in mind you won’t tell your three year-old the same thing you would tell your 10 year-old. If your child keeps asking questions it’s a pretty good indicator they either need a little more information or more reassurance that things will be ok. And if you don’t have an answer it’s ok to say “I don’t know, but I’ll try to find out.”

Whatever you decide, just hang in there. I know it can be trying. Sometimes I wondered if my kids were testing me.  A few of our award-winning family questions and answers include:

My oldest asked this when she was three years old, when we first started our business and her dad was working and traveling all the time. It was such a wake-up call. She truly wanted to know if he lived with us still. (He did and we were and are happily married.) But more importantly, she wanted to talk about how much she missed things. We didn’t realize how observant she was and even though they did spend good quality time together  it was confusing for her. We made significant changes after that. Including her in conversations about when he was leaving, where he was going and when he’d return. We measured time in “sleeps.”

Asked very loudly in the grocery store after seeing several pregnant women. My daughter was 5. I simply said moms have eggs and if they get fertilized they grow into babies. Thank goodness that was enough for her!

Sometimes the news is terrifying to kids. Even if you don’t let them see it on the TV they can see it in newspapers (where they still exist) or magazines in stores. Luckily a lot of things have gone digital so we can protect them a bit more. However, kids still can get access. This question came to us often after a tragic event. My answer was always to tell them that mom and dad will do everything we can to keep you safe. I would show them the locks on the doors and windows and talk about how much I loved them and how I was like a fierce momma bear. I also took the opportunity to teach them about calling 9-1-1.

Picture a child yelling that and pointing. Hard for the person not to hear and definitely harder to ignore. We talked about earrings and gauges and how that happens. We also talked about how it’s cool that everyone gets to have a personal style. They also have pointed out different body shapes and skin tones. I would always try to celebrate our differences with comments like “Isn’t it great we all come in different shapes and sizes and colors? Our world would be so boring if we all looked the same.”

My kids loved Scooby Doo. But, it instilled a very real fear of vampires in one of them. We talked about how vampires felt scary but weren’t real. But that didn’t help. So we put crosses up, garlic on her window sill and I made “monster spray” out of lavender oil and water to spray in her room and pillow at bedtime. Eventually she grew out of it.

At times, maybe the questions were irrelevant. Maybe it was just their way of seeking to find out if they could really trust that I would always be available to them. All I know is that they’re mostly grown now, still ask interesting questions and the dialogue continues. For that I am grateful!

What are some of the tough questions you've had to answer? If you have some tough questions you want help answering, send me a message and I’ll do my best to help.

Be kind to yourselves and others.

Until next time,

Recent Posts

Stormy Weather

August 11th, 2020|

We’re in rough waters. They’re unpredictable and hard to navigate. And most of us aren’t really trained to be so seaworthy. But, as many before us have done, we can and must persevere. Read more.

A Little Sweetness Goes A Long Way

July 28th, 2020|

Many of us already know the importance of building community and can do so naturally. But for those who are a little more reserved, how do you create that for your family—especially during a pandemic when the more natural ways of meeting people, developing friendships and nurturing relationships are less available? Read more.